Issue Brief: Orphan Works

SAA POSITION

In January 2013, SAA responded to the Copyright Office’s Notice of Inquiry Concerning Orphan Works and Mass Digitization [1].  SAA noted that any solution to the orphan works problem must:

  • Apply equally to mass digitization and individual items.
  • Balance the copyright owner’s interests with the diligence incumbent upon the user.
  • Draw a distinction between copyrighted works that were created with material gain in mind and those works that were never intended for the commercial market. Within archives, works created for commercial gain tend to be the exception and should not be the driving consideration in any debate about copyright.
  • Make it incumbent upon the rights holders of older works not currently being commercially exploited to record their ownership in a copyright registry. A “diligent search” would consist simply of an automated search of the registry.
  • Waive financial liability for those who make a non-commercial use of orphan works after an unsuccessful good faith effort to obtain permission from rights holders.   

SAA will, via its Intellectual Property Working Group, monitor and recommend appropriate actions on orphan works issues, both nationally and internationally.

THE ISSUE

Archival holdings consist almost entirely of unpublished works that were not created for commercial purposes. Among them are many orphan works of great research value. Users of archives wish to use such works in a wide variety of projects, and archival repositories wish to digitize them and make them available online to enhance their accessibility. But archivists’ fear of uncertainty and doubt surrounding the use of orphan works can lead to the following challenges for archives and their users:

  • Reduced availability of valuable historical resources,
  • Prohibitive costs of largely fruitless searches for rights holders,
  • Uncertainty about what constitutes a “diligent” search, and
  • Little interest by rights holders in exploiting their orphan works because of limited commercial value, rendering even cursory searches a waste of time—whether or not the rights holder responds.

Each of these concerns is discussed in more detail below.

If rights holders cannot be identified or located despite the best efforts of the researcher or the archives, research and digitization projects can be stymied. In theory, the limited damages available for unauthorized use of unregistered works should not serve as an impediment to their use.  In practice, however, projects often are changed or abandoned due to fears that 1) some of the material may have been published and registered and hence is subject to the draconian penalties in copyright law or 2) rights holders might surface and complain.  In addition, few archival repositories are willing to ignore possibly applicable laws just because the risks involved in doing so are small.  As a result, an archives might digitize only a portion of an archival collection, which compromises its integrity by presenting an incomplete picture. Consequently valuable cultural heritage remains hidden and is not available to serve the interests of society in furthering the growth of knowledge and culture.  

Documented research has revealed that the cost of the investigation required to identify and locate rights holders of non-commercial unpublished orphan works is inordinately high[2].  What constitutes a “good faith, reasonably diligent”[3] search?  The heterogeneous nature of archival holdings means that there is no single strategy to identify or locate rights holders. As the search continues beyond the most likely sources, further sources may suggest themselves but such sources are increasingly unlikely to yield results. There is no clear point at which enough research has been done; the next source might reveal the answer.  No matter how diligent, the searches for rights holders have rarely borne fruit.  Few rights holders have been identified as a result of time-consuming and costly research.

Finally, when they have been located, the owners of copyright in unpublished non-commercial orphan works rarely have any interest in exploiting their works and often grant royalty-free permission to use them. Most unpublished material found in archival repositories lacks sufficient commercial value to justify costly, but largely fruitless, searches.

BACKGROUND

There have always been works whose copyright owners cannot be identified or located. The problem for published works has been exacerbated by amendments to the Copyright Act that 1) eliminated the requirement for registration and a copyright notice and 2) changed the term of copyright from a fixed term based on the date of publication to one based on the life of the author plus 50 years (lengthened by a further 20 years by the 1998 Copyright Term Extension Act).

The orphan works problem was considered by the Copyright Office in 2006. After consultations with stakeholders, the Office issued a report recommending that users could exploit orphan works only after a “reasonably diligent [unsuccessful] search,” and should a rights holder later emerge, the amount of any penalty would be limited [4].  Legislation to implement these recommendations subsequently was introduced in Congress. Vigorous opposition from those whose works do not typically include rights information (particularly photographers) kept the legislation from passing.

The Copyright Office again considered the issue in 2012 when it issued a discussion document [5] and sought input “regarding the current state of play for orphan works, including … what additional legislative, regulatory, or voluntary solutions deserve deliberation at this time from stakeholders”[6].  SAA’s submission is summarized in this issue brief. The Copyright Office has not yet issued a report on the consultation.

 

[1] Dooley, Jackie, SAA President, Response by the Society of American Archivists to the Notice of Inquiry Concerning Orphan Works and Mass Digitization, 29 January 2013, online at http://www.copyright.gov/orphan/comments/noi_10222012/Society-American-Archivists.pdf.

[2] Dharma Akmon, “Only with Your Permission: How Rights Holders Respond (or Don’t Respond) to Requests to Display Archival Materials Online,” Archival Science 10 (2010):45-64; Maggie Dickson, "Due Diligence, Futile Effort: Copyright and the Digitization of the Thomas E. Watson Papers," American Archivist, 73:2 (2010): 626-636.

[3] “Recommended Statutory Language,” United States Copyright Office. Report on Orphan Works. Washington, DC, January 2006, http://www.copyright.gov/orphan/orphan-report-full.pdf, 127.

[4] United States Copyright Office. Report on Orphan Works. Washington, DC, January 2006 http://www.copyright.gov/orphan/orphan-report-full.pdf, 8, 93-122.

[5] United States Copyright Office. Legal Issues in Mass Digitization : A Preliminary Analysis and Discussion Document (Washington, DC., 2011), http://www.copyright.gov/docs/massdigitization/

[6] [Notice of inquiry], 77 FR 64560 October 22, 2012,  http://www.copyright.gov/fedreg/2012/77fr64555.pdf.

 

ADDITIONAL REFERENCE SOURCES

Approved by the Council:  May 2014

13 Comment(s) to the "Issue Brief: Orphan Works"
110184 says:
Smart HELOC Calculator

Orphan works are a headache. No one wants to take a risk with something that's likely worthless. Check out this tool for calculating risks on financial matters; it might not be the same, but helps think through the numbers. https://heloc-calculator.top/

Darwin Abbott says:
A key point made by SAA is

A key point made by SAA is the need for balanced solutions that respect copyright owners’ rights while not placing undue burdens on users and italian brainrot archives trying to make these materials accessible. Since many orphan works are unlikely to have commercial exploitation, the typical copyright concerns—aimed at protecting commercial interests—should not be the primary focus when dealing with archival materials. 

109165 says:
When playing space waves,

When playing space waves, control the arrow skillfully to be able to weave through narrow and thorny paths.

Cornelius says:
Telegram es una potente

Telegram es una potente plataforma de mensajería basada en la nube diseñada para la comunicación moderna. A diferencia de otras aplicaciones, Telegram se centra en la privacidad y la velocidad con funciones como Chats Secretos y sincronización entre dispositivos. Ya sea para hablar con tus amigos, ser parte de grupos públicos o seguir canales de Telegram, puedes contar con una experiencia de mensajería segura y sin complicaciones. La versión que ofrecemos aquí es diferente a la de Google Play Store. Estamos proporcionando un APK de Telegram para usuarios que tienen limitaciones con sus cuentas de Google o restricciones de red, y lo más importante, para aquellos que desean tener las funciones premium sin suscripción.

Cornelius says:
Telegram es una potente

Telegram es una potente plataforma de mensajería basada en la nube diseñada para la comunicación moderna. A diferencia de otras aplicaciones, Telegram se centra en la privacidad y la velocidad con funciones como Chats Secretos y sincronización entre dispositivos. Ya sea para hablar con tus amigos, ser parte de grupos públicos o seguir canales de Telegram, puedes contar con una experiencia de mensajería segura y sin complicaciones. La versión que ofrecemos aquí es diferente a la de Google Play Store. Estamos proporcionando un APK de Telegram para usuarios que tienen limitaciones con sus cuentas de Google o restricciones de red, y lo más importante, para aquellos que desean tener las funciones premium sin suscripción.

110184 says:
Free Online Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) Calculator

The orphan works issue is frustrating and a total barrier for archivists. It's like finding a needle in a haystack, and the stakes are low. At least there's a handy BAC calculator for those nights you’ll need it. https://bac-calculator.top/

Cornelius says:
Our variable dc power

Our variable dc power supplies include: programmable power supply, bench power supply, high voltage power supply, and high precision power supply. You can choose the appropriate dc power supply based on your specific requirements from our product range.

Cornelius says:
Planet Clicker is a

Planet Clicker is a resource-generating idle game where you click planets to earn and upgrade production. Start with Earth, unlock others, and automate growth. Control is simple: just click to grow your galaxy!

Cornelius says:
Block Blast is a fast-paced

Block Blast is a fast-paced puzzle game where players match colored blocks to clear the board. Use mouse/arrow keys to move and spacebar to rotate. Clear blocks quickly to score as high as possible before time runs out!

Cornelius says:
Welcome to Cheese Chompers

Welcome to Cheese Chompers 3D Cheese Chompers 3D is a hilarious fast-paced knockout game where you control wobbly rats in chaotic battles across a vibrant arena. Experience the thrill of pushing your opponents off the platform while trying to maintain your balance. With simple controls and physics-based gameplay, it's easy to learn but challenging to master. Play for free directly in your browser, no downloads required!

Cornelius says:
Experience Crazy Cattle

Experience Crazy Cattle 3D Crazy Cattle 3D offers an exhilarating battle royale experience unlike any other. As a sheep with explosive capabilities, your mission is to outmaneuver and outlast other ovine competitors in this chaotic survival game. Developed by an independent creator with a passion for unique gameplay, Crazy Cattle 3D combines humor with challenging mechanics. Players navigate through three distinct environments—Ireland, Iceland, and New Zealand—each presenting unique terrain challenges that affect your sheep's movement and strategy. What sets Crazy Cattle 3D apart is its physics-based movement system. Master the art of sheep locomotion to gain advantage over opponents, learning how to use momentum and timing to your benefit. The game rewards skill development and strategic thinking while maintaining its comedic undertones. Crazy Cattle 3D has quickly gained a dedicated community who appreciate its difficulty level and quirky premise. With an average session length of about 30 minutes, it offers the perfect balance between casual play and competitive challenge. Download Crazy Cattle 3D today and discover why players can't stop talking about this woolly battle royale phenomenon.

Cornelius says:
The EDM wire machinecombines

The EDM wire machinecombines electrical discharges with precise wire movement to cut materials with exceptional accuracy. Electrical Discharge: A thin wire, usually brass or copper, generates controlled electrical discharges to cut conductive materials. Non-Contact Process: The wire does not physically touch the workpiece; instead, sparks erode the material. Wire Movement: The wire is fed continuously from a spool, allowing precise and uninterrupted cutting. Deionized Water: Deionized water is used as a dielectric fluid to cool the process and flush away debris. Heat and Material Removal: The sparks create localized heat, vaporizing the material at the cutting point. CNC Precision: CNC control ensures high accuracy for intricate and complex shapes, ideal for tight tolerances.

Cornelius says:
Tik Tok (Douyin Overseas

Tik Tok (Douyin Overseas Edition)-¡El centro de creación de vídeos cortos al que acuden 2.500 millones de usuarios de todo el mundo! Aquí, puede publicar una enseñanza de baile, un párrafo divertido o un vídeo de desafío popular en 15 segundos, y el algoritmo inteligente empuja con precisión los puntos calientes de moda que le interesan; la función de colaboración de una sola tecla vincula a creadores extranjeros, y el área de comentarios se convierte en un campo social transnacional en un segundo; y la sala de transmisión en vivo pasa a través de las golosinas transfronterizas, ¡y puede desbloquear una nueva experiencia de consumo mientras ve y compra! Tik Tok, como homólogo global de Douyin, continúa el marco interactivo central de su producto matriz y remodela la escena del entretenimiento y el consumo con el modo de "contenido breve + fuerte interacción", convirtiéndose en un espacio digital inmersivo con creación, socialización y valor comercial. Cientos de millones de usuarios conectan el mundo con sus lentes cada día, ¿a qué esperas? ¡Haz clic para descargar Tik Tok APK y captura tus momentos más destacados con vídeos cortos!